2019 Rookie of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alex Speier | AL | Alvarez | Means | Jimenez |
| Alyson Footer | AL | Alvarez | Guerrero | Jimenez |
| Andrew Baggarly | NL | Soroka | Alonso | Tatis |
| Anri Uechi | AL | Alvarez | Means | Lowe |
| Arden Zwelling | AL | Alvarez | Means | Lowe |
| Barry Bloom | NL | Alonso | Tatis | Hudson |
| Ben Frederickson | NL | Alonso | Reynolds | Soroka |
| Benjamin Hochman | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Bernie Wilson | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Betsy Helfand | AL | Alvarez | Means | Lowe |
| Bruce Miles | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Byron Kerr | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Reynolds |
| Chris Haft | AL | Alvarez | Arraez | Jimenez |
| Dan Connolly | AL | Alvarez | Means | Jimenez |
| Dan Szymborski | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Daniel Kramer | AL | Alvarez | Means | Arraez |
| Deesha Thosar | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Do-Hyoung Park | AL | Alvarez | Means | Arraez |
| Eddie Matz | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Eduardo A. Encina | AL | Alvarez | Lowe | Means |
| Eno Sarris | AL | Alvarez | Biggio | Lowe |
| Evan Woodbery | AL | Alvarez | Biggio | Means |
| Fabian Ardaya | AL | Alvarez | Lowe | Means |
| Gordon Wittenmyer | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Hideki Okuda | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Jason Mackey | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Reynolds |
| Jason Mastrodonato | AL | Alvarez | Means | Biggio |
| Jesse Sanchez | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Reynolds |
| Jesus Ortiz | AL | Alvarez | Means | Jimenez |
| Jim Alexander | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Jim Ingraham | AL | Alvarez | Jimenez | Mercado |
| JJ Cooper | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Joe Noga | AL | Alvarez | Lowe | Mercado |
| Joel Sherman | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Reynolds |
| John Maffei | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Josh Tolentino | AL | Alvarez | Means | Lowe |
| Ken Davidoff | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Robles |
| Kevin Sherrington | AL | Alvarez | Means | Lowe |
| Kyle Glaser | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Laura Armstrong | AL | Alvarez | Lowe | Jimenez |
| Lindsey Adler | AL | Alvarez | Lowe | Means |
| Lynn Worthy | AL | Alvarez | Jimenez | Mercado |
| Mac Engel | AL | Alvarez | Means | Guerrero |
| Maria Guardado | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Mark Schmetzer | NL | Alonso | Hudson | Reynolds |
| Meg Rowley | AL | Alvarez | Means | Lowe |
| Meghan Montemurro | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Nick Groke | NL | Alonso | Tatis | Soroka |
| Pat Caputo | AL | Alvarez | Lowe | Means |
| Patrick Graham | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Paul Sullivan | AL | Alvarez | Jimenez | Lowe |
| Roberto Colon | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Ron Cook | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Sam Mellinger | AL | Alvarez | Means | Lowe |
| Todd Zolecki | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| Tom Haudricourt | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Reynolds |
| Tony Andracki | AL | Alvarez | Means | Jimenez |
| Wells Dusenbury | NL | Alonso | Soroka | Tatis |
| William Lloyd Ladson | AL | Alvarez | Jimenez | Guerrero |
| Yuichi Matsushita | AL | Alvarez | Means | Jimenez |