2017 Rookie of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abbey Mastracco | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Bell |
| Alyson Footer | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Gurriel |
| Andre C. Fernandez | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Hoskins |
| Anthony Andro | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Barney Hutchinson | NL | Bellinger | Freeland | DeJong |
| Benjamin Hochman | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Marquez |
| Bernie Pleskoff | NL | Bellinger | Hoskins | DeJong |
| Brian Golden | NL | Bellinger | Bell | Hoskins |
| Bruce Miles | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Happ |
| Carl Steward | NL | Bellinger | Bell | Hoskins |
| Chris Assenheimer | AL | Judge | Mancini | Benintendi |
| Daniel Brown | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Dave Cameron | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Castillo |
| David Ginsburg | AL | Judge | Mancini | Benintendi |
| Eno Sarris | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Hoskins |
| Evan Woodbery | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Montgomery |
| George Sipple | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Hideki Okuda | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Hirokazu Higuchi | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |
| Janie McCauley | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Jeff Sanders | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Margot |
| Jeff Sullivan | AL | Judge | Montgomery | Benintendi |
| Jeffrey Flanagan | AL | Judge | Mancini | Benintendi |
| Jesse Sanchez | NL | Bellinger | Marquez | Margot |
| JJ Cooper | NL | Bellinger | Marquez | DeJong |
| Joe Kay | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |
| Joel Sherman | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |
| John Fay | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Marquez |
| John Perrotto | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Bell |
| John Shipley | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Jose de Jesus Ortiz | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |
| Justin Bopp | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Keith Law | NL | Bellinger | Margot | Hoskins |
| Kevin Sherrington | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Kirk Kenney | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |
| Laura Armstrong | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| LaVelle E. Neal III | AL | Judge | Mancini | Gurriel |
| Marc Topkin | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Mark Zuckerman | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Hoskins |
| Matthew Ehalt | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Hoskins |
| Meghan Montemurro | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Hoskins |
| Michael Silverman | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Olson |
| Mike Mazzeo | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Gurriel |
| Nick Groke | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Marquez |
| Patrick Mooney | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |
| Paul Sullivan | AL | Judge | Olson | Benintendi |
| Pete Abraham | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Peter Caldera | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Rich Dubroff | AL | Judge | Mancini | Benintendi |
| Roger Mooney | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Ron Cook | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |
| Ryan Lawrence | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Hoskins |
| Ryan Lewis | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Olson |
| Scott Merkin | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Gurriel |
| Shi Davidi | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Steve Buffery | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Steve Dilbeck | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Mancini |
| Tim Booth | AL | Judge | Benintendi | Gurriel |
| Tim Healey | NL | Bellinger | DeJong | Marquez |
| William Lloyd Ladson | NL | Bellinger | Bell | DeJong |