Manager of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Year | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AJ Cassavell | 2016 | NL | Maddon | Roberts | Mattingly |
| AJ Cassavell | 2017 | NL | Counsell | Black | Lovullo |
| AJ Cassavell | 2018 | NL | Counsell | Snitker | Black |
| Alex Speier | 2014 | AL | Showalter | Scioscia | McClendon |
| Alyson Footer | 2018 | AL | Melvin | Cora | Hinch |
| Amanda Housenick | 2012 | NL | Bochy | Gonzalez | Johnson |
| Andre C. Fernandez | 2018 | NL | Counsell | Snitker | Black |
| Andy McCullough | 2013 | AL | Francona | Girardi | Farrell |
| Andy McCullough | 2015 | AL | Banister | Yost | Molitor |
| Angel H. Verdejo Jr. | 2016 | AL | Showalter | Francona | Banister |
| Ann Killion | 2014 | NL | Williams | Hurdle | Bochy |
| Anthony Andro | 2014 | AL | Showalter | Yost | McClendon |
| Anthony Andro | 2012 | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Washington |
| Anthony Castrovince | 2017 | AL | Molitor | Francona | Hinch |
| Asuka Brown | 2012 | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Maddon |
| Asuka Iinuma Brown | 2013 | AL | Melvin | Maddon | Showalter |
| Aurelio Moreno | 2012 | NL | Bochy | Baker | Johnson |
| Aurelio Moreno | 2016 | NL | Roberts | Baker | Maddon |
| Barry Bloom | 2016 | NL | Roberts | Maddon | Baker |
| Barry Bloom | 2017 | NL | Lovullo | Baker | Black |
| Benjamin Hochman | 2018 | NL | Snitker | Counsell | Maddon |
| Benjamin Hochman | 2014 | NL | Hurdle | Bochy | Mattingly |
| Bernie Wilson | 2018 | NL | Snitker | Counsell | Black |
| Beth Harris | 2018 | NL | Snitker | Black | Counsell |
| Bill Center | 2014 | NL | Williams | Matheny | Mattingly |
| Bill Center | 2012 | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Black |
| Bill Evans | 2013 | NL | Hurdle | Gonzalez | Matheny |
| Bill Madden | 2012 | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Bill Madden | 2013 | AL | Farrell | Francona | Girardi |
| Bill Plunkett | 2017 | NL | Lovullo | Roberts | Black |
| Bill West | 2015 | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Hurdle |
| Bob Dutton | 2012 | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Ventura |
| Bob Hunter | 2012 | NL | Baker | Johnson | Bochy |
| Bob Hunter | 2014 | NL | Williams | Hurdle | Mattingly |
| Bob Klapisch | 2017 | AL | Francona | Molitor | Girardi |
| Bob Klapisch | 2014 | NL | Williams | Mattingly | Hurdle |
| Bob Nightengale | 2012 | NL | Baker | Johnson | Bochy |
| Bob Nightengale | 2013 | NL | Hurdle | Mattingly | Gonzalez |
| Bob Nightengale | 2015 | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| Brendan Kuty | 2019 | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Brian Golden | 2019 | NL | Roberts | Snitker | Shildt |
| Brian Golden | 2013 | AL | Francona | Maddon | Farrell |
| Brian Golden | 2018 | NL | Snitker | Shildt | Black |
| Brian MacPherson | 2013 | AL | Farrell | Francona | Girardi |
| Brian McNally | 2013 | NL | Hurdle | Matheny | Mattingly |
| Brian McTaggart | 2017 | AL | Molitor | Hinch | Francona |
| Brian McTaggart | 2018 | AL | Melvin | Hinch | Cora |
| Brittany Ghiroli | 2017 | AL | Molitor | Hinch | Girardi |
| Bruce Jenkins | 2017 | NL | Baker | Roberts | Lovullo |
| Bruce Levine | 2018 | NL | Maddon | Counsell | Snitker |
| Bruce Levine | 2019 | AL | Boone | Melvin | Baldelli |
| Bruce Levine | 2015 | AL | Girardi | Molitor | Banister |
| Bruce Levine | 2012 | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Bryan Burwell | 2014 | NL | Williams | Matheny | Bochy |
| Bryan Hoch | 2018 | AL | Cora | Melvin | Cash |
| Bryce Miller | 2019 | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Martinez |
| Byron Kerr | 2018 | NL | Snitker | Black | Counsell |
| Carl Steward | 2012 | NL | Bochy | Baker | Johnson |
| Carlos Alvarado | 2012 | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Chad Jennings | 2015 | AL | Hinch | Banister | Molitor |
| Chad Jennings | 2014 | AL | Showalter | McClendon | Scioscia |
| Chad Jennings | 2016 | AL | Francona | Farrell | Showalter |
| Charles Odum | 2018 | NL | Snitker | Counsell | Black |
| Charles Odum | 2015 | NL | Maddon | Collins | Matheny |
| Chase Hughes | 2015 | NL | Maddon | Collins | Matheny |
| Chris Assenheimer | 2016 | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| Chris Assenheimer | 2019 | AL | Cash | Melvin | Boone |
| Chris Assenheimer | 2012 | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Ventura |
| Chris Cotillo | 2019 | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| Chris Cwik | 2019 | AL | Boone | Hinch | Baldelli |
| Chris Cwik | 2018 | AL | Melvin | Cora | Cash |
| Chris Iott | 2012 | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Girardi |
| Chris Jenkins | 2014 | NL | Bochy | Roenicke | Hurdle |
| Chris Jenkins | 2015 | NL | Maddon | Collins | Hurdle |
| Christina Kahrl | 2016 | AL | Francona | Banister | Girardi |
| Christina Kahrl | 2013 | AL | Francona | Melvin | Maddon |
| Clark Spencer | 2017 | NL | Lovullo | Roberts | Baker |
| Coley Harvey | 2019 | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Cory McCartney | 2019 | NL | Snitker | Shildt | Counsell |
| Craig Davis | 2013 | NL | Hurdle | Gonzalez | Matheny |
| Dan Bickley | 2013 | NL | Hurdle | Mattingly | Gonzalez |
| Dan Martin | 2013 | NL | Hurdle | Mattingly | Gonzalez |
| Dan McGrath | 2014 | NL | Hurdle | Williams | Matheny |
| Dan Myers | 2016 | AL | Banister | Showalter | Francona |
| Daniel Brown | 2019 | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| Daniel Brown | 2018 | AL | Melvin | Cash | Cora |
| Daniel Brown | 2013 | AL | Francona | Farrell | Melvin |
| Daniel Brown | 2016 | NL | Baker | Maddon | Roberts |
| Daniel Brown | 2015 | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| Dave Cameron | 2014 | NL | Hurdle | Redmond | Mattingly |
| Dave Campbell | 2015 | AL | Banister | Gibbons | Molitor |
| Dave Campbell | 2019 | AL | Baldelli | Francona | Boone |
| Dave Skretta | 2014 | AL | Showalter | Yost | Scioscia |
| Dave Skretta | 2019 | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Hinch |
| Dave Skretta | 2018 | AL | Cora | Cash | Boone |
| Dave Skretta | 2016 | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| David Barron | 2015 | AL | Hinch | Banister | Molitor |
| David Barron | 2017 | AL | Molitor | Hinch | Francona |
| David Barron | 2016 | AL | Banister | Francona | Showalter |
| David Brown | 2019 | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |