2019 Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AJ Cassavell | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Flaherty | Ryu | Strasburg |
| Alyson Footer | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Bill Plunkett | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg | Gray |
| Brian McTaggart | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Lynn | Giolito |
| Bryan Hoch | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Lynn |
| C. Trent Rosecrans | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Scherzer | Gray |
| Charles Odum | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Scherzer | Strasburg | Soroka |
| Chris Mason | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Daryl Van Schouwen | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Lynn | Bieber |
| David O'Brien | NL | deGrom | Strasburg | Flaherty | Ryu | Soroka |
| Dennis Lin | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Strasburg | Flaherty |
| Eno Sarris | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Flaherty | Soroka |
| Evan Grant | AL | Cole | Verlander | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| Greg Beacham | AL | Cole | Verlander | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| Jack Etkin | NL | deGrom | Flaherty | Ryu | Scherzer | Gray |
| Jack McCaffery | NL | deGrom | Strasburg | Kershaw | Ryu | Scherzer |
| Janie McCauley | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Lynn |
| Jason Beck | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Lynn | Bieber |
| Jeff Fletcher | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Jeff Wilson | AL | Verlander | Cole | Bieber | Morton | Minor |
| Jeffrey Flanagan | AL | Verlander | Cole | Bieber | Minor | Giolito |
| Jenifer Langosch | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Scherzer | Strasburg | Flaherty |
| Joe Trezza | AL | Verlander | Cole | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| John Fay | NL | deGrom | Flaherty | Soroka | Ryu | Gray |
| John Perrotto | NL | deGrom | Strasburg | Scherzer | Ryu | Flaherty |
| John Romano | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Minor |
| John Shea | AL | Verlander | Cole | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| Jon Heyman | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg | Scherzer |
| Jon Paul Morosi | AL | Cole | Verlander | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| Jorge Ebro | NL | deGrom | Flaherty | Scherzer | Ryu | Strasburg |
| Katsushi Nagao | NL | deGrom | Flaherty | Scherzer | Ryu | Strasburg |
| Kerry Crowley | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg | Scherzer |
| Larry Stone | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Mark Didtler | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Rodriguez |
| Mark Gonzales | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg |
| Mark Saxon | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg |
| Mark Whicker | NL | Ryu | deGrom | Flaherty | Yates | Strasburg |
| Mark Zuckerman | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg | Scherzer |
| Matt Breen | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Scherzer | Strasburg |
| Mike Puma | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Scherzer | Flaherty | Soroka |
| Nick Piecoro | NL | deGrom | Strasburg | Flaherty | Scherzer | Ryu |
| Nubyjas Wilborn | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Strasburg | Soroka |
| Patrick Borzi | AL | Verlander | Cole | Bieber | Rodriguez | Morton |
| Peter Caldera | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Lynn |
| Phil Miller | AL | Verlander | Cole | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| Rob Longley | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Rodriguez | Bieber |
| Robert Murray | NL | deGrom | Strasburg | Scherzer | Buehler | Flaherty |
| Roch Kubatko | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Rodriguez |
| Rustin Dodd | AL | Cole | Verlander | Minor | Morton | Bieber |
| Ryan Divish | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Bieber | Lynn |
| Ryan Lewis | AL | Cole | Verlander | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| Scott Merkin | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Scott Mitchell | AL | Cole | Verlander | Bieber | Morton | Lynn |
| Sean McAdam | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Steve Gilbert | NL | deGrom | Strasburg | Scherzer | Flaherty | Ryu |
| Thomas Harding | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Strasburg | Corbin |
| Tim Healey | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Scherzer | Soroka |
| Todd Dybas | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg |
| Tom Haudricourt | NL | deGrom | Flaherty | Strasburg | Scherzer | Ryu |
| Tom Withers | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Rodriguez | Bieber |