2015 Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Rubin | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | deGrom |
| Andrew Baggarly | NL | Kershaw | Arrieta | Greinke | Scherzer | Bumgarner |
| Andy McCullough | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Sale | Archer |
| Barney Hutchinson | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Cole | Bumgarner |
| Bernie Miklasz | NL | Arrieta | Kershaw | Greinke | Cole | Scherzer |
| Bernie Wilson | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | Melancon |
| Bill Plunkett | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | deGrom | Scherzer |
| Bob Dutton | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Hernandez | Archer |
| Bob Klapisch | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | deGrom | Scherzer |
| C. Trent Rosecrans | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| Chris Iott | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Sale |
| Colleen Kane | AL | Keuchel | Price | Sale | Gray | Archer |
| Daryl Van Schouwen | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Sale | Archer |
| Dave Cameron | NL | Arrieta | Kershaw | Greinke | Scherzer | Bumgarner |
| David Barron | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Hernandez | McHugh |
| David Ginsburg | AL | Keuchel | Price | Hernandez | Gray | McHugh |
| Drew Olson | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| Evan Grant | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Sale |
| Hal McCoy | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Cole | Bumgarner | Kershaw |
| Jack Magruder | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Cole | Scherzer |
| Jeff Fletcher | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Kluber |
| Jeff Miller | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | Melancon |
| Jeff Passan | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Sale |
| Jerry Crasnick | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Bumgarner |
| Jesse Rogers | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | Melancon |
| Jim Ingraham | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Carrasco | Sale |
| Joe Stiglich | AL | Price | Keuchel | Gray | Sale | Archer |
| Joe Strauss | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Cole | Scherzer |
| John Harper | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | deGrom |
| John Maffei | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | Melancon |
| John Perrotto | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Cole | Melancon |
| John Shea | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Bumgarner |
| Jon Heyman | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| Ken Fidlin | AL | Price | Keuchel | Gray | Archer | Davis |
| Kristie Rieken | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Hernandez | McHugh |
| Larry Stone | AL | Price | Keuchel | Gray | Sale | Davis |
| Lynn Henning | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Davis | Tolleson |
| Manny Navarro | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Cole | Kershaw | deGrom |
| Mark Feinsand | AL | Price | Keuchel | Gray | Archer | Betances |
| Mark Gonzales | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | Scherzer |
| Mark Whicker | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Miller | Davis |
| Martin Fennelly | AL | Price | Keuchel | Davis | Tolleson | Miller |
| Matt Baker | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Sale | Archer |
| Matt Kawahara | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Sale | Archer |
| Meghan Montemurro | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| Mel Antonen | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Cole | Lackey |
| Nick Groke | NL | Kershaw | Greinke | Arrieta | Scherzer | Cole |
| Patrick Borzi | AL | Price | Keuchel | Gray | McHugh | Davis |
| Paul White | AL | Keuchel | Gray | Price | Archer | Estrada |
| Peter Caldera | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Sale |
| Phil Miller | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Davis |
| Ryan Fagan | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| Ryan Lawrence | NL | Kershaw | Greinke | Arrieta | Scherzer | Bumgarner |
| Sean McAdam | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Sale |
| Shi Davidi | AL | Price | Keuchel | Sale | Kluber | Archer |
| Stefan Stevenson | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Estrada | Sale |
| Tim Britton | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Sale | Kluber |
| Travis Sawchik | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| Zach Buchanan | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| Zack Meisel | AL | Price | Keuchel | Sale | Gray | Archer |