2014 Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alex Pavlovic | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Zimmermann |
| Andrew Gruman | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Greinke | Zimmermann |
| Anthony McCarron | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Greinke |
| Barney Hutchinson | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Fister |
| Bernie Miklasz | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Cueto | Zimmermann | Strasburg |
| Brendan Kennedy | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Hughes |
| Bruce Miles | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Kimbrel |
| Dan Barbarisi | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Lester | Price |
| Dan Hayes | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Dennis Lin | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Greinke |
| Dennis Manoloff | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Scherzer | Sale | Lester |
| Drew Olson | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Hamels |
| Erik Boland | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Evan Drellich | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Price | Sale | Lester |
| Gerry Fraley | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Scherzer | Sale | Davis |
| Gordon Wittenmyer | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Bumgarner |
| Guy Curtright | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Cueto | Bumgarner | Zimmermann |
| J.P. Hoornstra | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Zimmermann |
| Jack Magruder | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Hamels |
| James Schmehl | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Jeff Sanders | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Cueto | Strasburg |
| Jim Ingraham | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Scherzer | Lester |
| Jim Salisbury | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Hamels |
| Joe Posnanski | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Price | Davis |
| Joe Stiglich | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Lester | Price | Sale |
| Joe Strauss | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Greinke | Zimmermann |
| John Fay | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Arrieta |
| John McGrath | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Scherzer | Hughes |
| John Perrotto | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Cueto | Hamels | Kimbrel |
| John Shea | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Zimmermann |
| Joseph Smith | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Juan C. Rodriguez | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Cueto | Bumgarner | Zimmermann |
| Justin McGuire | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Hamels | Fister |
| Ken Fidlin | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Ken Rosenthal | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Price | Lester | Sale |
| Kevin Cooney | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Hamels | Arrieta |
| LaVelle E. Neal III | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Lester | Hughes |
| Manny Navarro | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Cueto | Fister | Alvarez |
| Marc Carig | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Hamels | Zimmermann |
| Mark Saxon | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Hamels | Bumgarner |
| Mark Schmetzer | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Kimbrel |
| Mark Zuckerman | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Fister |
| Martin Fennelly | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Scherzer | Holland |
| Matt Kawahara | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Lester | Price |
| Matthew B. Mowery | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Michael Silverman | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Price | Lester |
| Naoko Sato | AL | Hernandez | Sale | Kluber | Scherzer | Lester |
| Nick Cafardo | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Nick Groke | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Hamels |
| Patrick Borzi | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Lester | Scherzer | Sale |
| Pedro Moura | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Hughes | Lester |
| Pete Abraham | AL | Hernandez | Sale | Kluber | Lester | Hughes |
| Rich Dubroff | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Scherzer | Sale | Davis |
| Ryan Divish | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Scherzer | Lester |
| Sam Mellinger | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Lester | Sale | Scherzer |
| Tim Brown | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Lester | Price |
| Tim Kurkjian | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Hamels |
| Travis Sawchik | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Strasburg |
| Yuzo Hayakawa | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Scherzer | Lester | Price |
| Zach Buchanan | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Cueto | Hamels | Arrieta |