2012 Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alex Pavlovic | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Cueto | Gonzalez | Cain |
| Alvin Valdez | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Cain | Lohse |
| Ben Goessling | AL | Verlander | Price | Hernandez | Sale | Darvish |
| Bernie Miklasz | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Cueto | Gonzalez | Lohse |
| Bill Ballou | AL | Price | Verlander | Weaver | Hernandez | Harrison |
| Bill Center | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Kimbrel | Chapman |
| Bill Plunkett | AL | Price | Weaver | Verlander | Rodney | Sale |
| Bob Klapisch | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kershaw | Cueto | Kimbrel |
| Brian Costa | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cueto | Kimbrel |
| Bruce Jenkins | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Sale | Hernandez |
| Bruce Miles | NL | Dickey | Cueto | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cain |
| Chad Jennings | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Sale |
| Chris Jenkins | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Cain | Kershaw |
| Dan Barbarisi | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Sale |
| Danny Knobler | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kimbrel | Cueto | Kershaw |
| Dave van Dyck | AL | Price | Verlander | Hernandez | Sale | Weaver |
| Dejan Kovacevic | NL | Dickey | Cueto | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Gonzalez |
| Dennis Manoloff | AL | Price | Verlander | Sale | Weaver | Harrison |
| Dennis Punzel | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Cueto | Gonzalez |
| Derrick Goold | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Cueto | Lohse | Kimbrel |
| Drew Davison | AL | Rodney | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez |
| Drew Olson | NL | Dickey | Cueto | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Kimbrel |
| Gerry Fraley | AL | Price | Verlander | Weaver | Rodney | Johnson |
| Guy Curtright | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kimbrel | Cueto | Kershaw |
| Jack Etkin | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Gonzalez | Cueto |
| Jack Magruder | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Cueto | Gonzalez | Kimbrel |
| Jerry Crasnick | NL | Kershaw | Dickey | Kimbrel | Gonzalez | Cain |
| Jim Ingraham | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Sale |
| Jim Salisbury | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kershaw | Cueto | Cain |
| Joe Christensen | AL | Verlander | Price | Rodney | Hernandez | Weaver |
| Joe Posnanski | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Sale |
| John Fay | NL | Cueto | Dickey | Kershaw | Lohse | Gonzalez |
| John Harper | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cain | Kimbrel |
| John Hickey | AL | Price | Verlander | Weaver | Johnson | Hernandez |
| John Shea | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Cain |
| Jon Paul Morosi | AL | Price | Verlander | Hernandez | Weaver | Rodney |
| Jorge Ortiz | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Rodney |
| Joseph Smith | AL | Price | Verlander | Rodney | Weaver | Hernandez |
| Ken Fidlin | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Rodney |
| Ken Rosenthal | AL | Price | Verlander | Weaver | Hernandez | Rodney |
| Larry Stone | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Rodney |
| Lynn Henning | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Rodney | Sale |
| Manny Navarro | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Cain | Kershaw |
| Mark Schmetzer | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Kershaw | Hamels |
| Mark Zuckerman | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Cueto |
| Martin Fennelly | AL | Price | Verlander | Rodney | Weaver | Johnson |
| Mel Antonen | AL | Price | Verlander | Rodney | Weaver | Johnson |
| Michael Martinez | AL | Price | Weaver | Verlander | Rodney | Hernandez |
| Mike Puma | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cueto | Kimbrel |
| Patrick Saunders | NL | Gonzalez | Dickey | Kershaw | Cain | Kimbrel |
| Paul Sullivan | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cain | Cueto | Kershaw |
| Rob Bradford | AL | Verlander | Price | Hernandez | Weaver | Rodney |
| Ron Cook | NL | Dickey | Cueto | Gonzalez | Kimbrel | Kershaw |
| Sam Mellinger | AL | Verlander | Price | Hernandez | Weaver | Rodney |
| Scot Gregor | AL | Price | Verlander | Weaver | Sale | Rodney |
| Shi Davidi | AL | Price | Verlander | Rodney | Weaver | Hernandez |
| Steve Dilbeck | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cueto | Cain |
| Tim Brown | NL | Kershaw | Dickey | Cueto | Gonzalez | Cain |
| Tim Kurkjian | NL | Kimbrel | Dickey | Kershaw | Cueto | Gonzalez |
| Tony DeMarco | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cain | Kimbrel |